Whether mankind stemmed from creation or evolution, gender roles have played an
important role in society since the beginning of time. Due to our innate
biological difference man and woman each have separate roles and stereotypes
associated with their functions. Many literary works have delved into this
practice and Mark Twain’s “The Diary of Adam and Eve” is no different. As we
read through the diary that was written by the first man and woman we see how
they embrace the role of the gender they were given. We not only see them
exhibiting their own gender roles but also see how they examine the gender
roles of their counter part. Twain’s use of gender stereotypes gives us insight
on how the gender roles were in the early 1900’s, as both of these stories were
published in 1904. We first read through Adam’s diary and then Eve’s allowing
us to compare their reactions of the same event.
Until he
had to adjust to Eve’s arrival, Adam as the first human experienced life in the
Garden of Eden with just the animals; once she arrived Adam embraced the
stereotypical characteristics of a man. When he was concerned that something
problematic might occur he took this opportunity to flea in order to avoid the
chaos that was to ensue, “I escaped last night, and rode a horse all night as
fast as I could go, hoping to get clear out of the Park and hide in some other
country before trouble should begin…” (Twain 330). As Eve had just arrived in
his life—and since he believed she was at fault—Adam felt no desire to bring
her with him. This is very typical of a young man especially one that has no
connections with people, to just leave when they see a problem arriving. But as
the story progresses we see Adam’s behavior, which resembles a man maturing and
starting to understand his responsibilities. After he received ‘knowledge’ from
biting into the apple, he discovered Eve is someone he wants to keep around, “I
see I should be lonesome and depressed without her, now that I have lost my
property….She will be useful” (Twain 331). Although he might be using her just
to replace that which he has lost, he does see a ‘use’ out of her.
While Adam
eventually finds a use for Eve, he initially was not fond of her, which is made
very evident in her perception of her. Through his perception we are able to
see some of Eve’s typical gender roles and Adam’s interpretation of them. This
interpretation, or misinterpretation as it would be, is seen in one of their
first interactions, when Eve attempts to enter a shelter that Adam made. Adam
said, “The new creature intruded. When I tried to put it out it shed water out
of the holes it looks with, and wiped it away with the back of its paws, and
made a noise such as some of the other animals make when they are in distress”
(Twain 326). Just the way in which Adam describes Eve’s crying proves that he
does not understand women. Also he continues to call her ‘creature’ because he
does not fully understand that she is a woman and a part of him. Eve’s crying
is not the only misinterpretation on the part of Adam, Eve enjoys going and
sitting next to the pond, and Adam believes she is doing this to look at
herself, “She fell in the pond yesterday when she was looking at herself in it,
which she is always doing.” (Twain 329). In reality, we learn that Eve actually
believed this reflection to be a friend of hers and enjoyed sitting next to the
pond to keep from being lonely. While Adam does have some interpretations of
Eve’s behavior, we can also see Eve’s female gender stereotypes in her own
diary.
Eve
exhibits many female characteristics throughout her diary. Even just her diary
itself fulfills a female stereotype, the fact that her diary is almost twice as
long as that of Adam’s exemplifies the woman’s desire to talk and never stop
talking. If this is not enough, Eve explicitly says how much she enjoys
talking, “…I love to talk; I talk, all day, and in my sleep, too, and I am very
interesting, but if I had another to talk to I could be twice as interesting,
and would never stop, if desired” (Twain 340). Sometimes it is not just the
length of the discussion that is stereotypical but also the topic of
discussion. Woman enjoy talking about something men never wish to talk about or
hear about, their feelings. Eve exhibits this with an emotional rant in the
starting paragraph, “For I feel like an experiment, I feel exactly like an
experiment; it would be impossible for a person to feel more like an experiment
than I do, and so I am coming to feel convinced that that is what I am—an experiment; just an experiment,
and nothing more” (Twain 337). She feels like an experiment and although her
and Adam were created in the same manner and she calls him a man she is merely an experiment. This
goes towards woman’s stereotype of not only being emotional but insecure about
who they are and themselves. In all her lengthy discussion Eve does discuss
Adam and some of his behaviors as well.
Eve enjoys
watching Adam and examining what he is doing in. At one point he is lying
around and she becomes very critical of his lack of actions, “It looks to me
like a creature that is more interested in resting than in anything else”
(Twain 340). She is reading into him lying down as him being lazy and desiring
resting more than anything else. Which is as much a stereotypes for men as they
are for women. While man does enjoy lying around when he gets the opportunity
woman do enjoy criticizing them for doing this. We also see Adam’s
transformation through Eve as he starts to grow more concerned for her and
starts to care about her. When she tries to get him to eat the apple he says, “They
are forbidden and he says you shall come to harm…” (Twain 342). While he is very blunt he is starting to
become protective and concerned for Eve.
Throughout
Adam and Eve’s Diaries we are able to see them embrace their gender
stereotypes. Not only are they embracing their stereotypes but they are
beginning to understand the gender roles of the other. This mirrors men and
women in society and as they age they must either embrace their genders
stereotypes or go against them. And as they are doing this they also learn
about the opposite genders roles. It is all a transformation that must occur
within society.
I think your analysis of the stereotypes is very good. What puzzles me is how much of Twain's view of genders is due to his personal beliefs and how much has to do with the ideas of the time? Or if perhaps this is a jab at the gender beliefs of the time? I guess I wonder how this story might differ if it was written today, or would it differ at all?
ReplyDeleteI realize I am asking questions and not answering any, but I really am somewhat stumped on how much of this story is a product of his time.
I think that Twain is trying to demonstrate the ideas of his time. I always feel when I am reading Twain that he is making fun of what society does and this tory is no different. He uses his exaggeration to show how ridiculous the extreme gender roles are. As for if the story would be different today, well that is a great question, it would depend on a lot of factors such as the setting of the story and the social situation of the characters; because while woman have advanced in society and taken on new roles there are some people who still carry out the traditional gender roles (and it could be because they want to).
DeleteTwain's explanation of gender roles seems like he is telling a story of "boy meets girl". He starts with Adam acting very childish towards Eve, and then progresses to fall in love her. I feel like he is almost making a mockery of gender roles by showing the silliness of gender typing.
ReplyDeleteTo start, I thought this story was an ambitious project. Twain attempts to illustrate stereotypes within genders, but decides to use the two blankest slates in history. Two humans, new to existence, who have not had the same social constructs pushed upon them by society. There has not been any tradition before their time that tells them how they should act or feel about their circumstances.
ReplyDeleteSo that means this could be read in a couple different ways. Adam and Eve may not have had any social pretext for the behaviors they exhibit, but those behaviors certainly seem gendered as Kara has pointed out. Does this mean these gendered mannerisms are all biological? Eve's longer thoughtful diary entries tell us much more about how she feels and sees everything as she is learning. Is that a result of her femininity? Adam's behavior is more disconnected and standoffish. A biological homage to his masculinity? I don't agree with this view.
Twain could also be projecting the gender norms at his time and merely be poking fun at them. According to Adam, Eve is demanding, bossy, vain, and may have some trouble with the internal plumbing, "...it shed water out of the holes it looks with..." (Twain 325). Take a look at Eve's journals, however, and we see that Adam is dismissive and does not wish to spend his time learning about the world they have so miraculously been made together in. This discrepancy in feminine and masculine views is a common theme in literature as well as current entertainment, as Kara has mentioned, but why are these discrepancies so entertaining? Does that mean we also believe and take part in gender specific behaviors?
For me, these two ideas centered on a few lines in the diary entry titled, "After The Fall." "Then why is it that I love him? Merely because he is masculine, I think" (Twain 352). Depending on how that passage is interpreted can change the meaning of the entire story. Curse you Twain!